Earnings quality: does the profit arrive as cash?

Level: Intermediate 5 minutes · Last reviewed on Oct 13, 2026

A profit appears in the income statement, cash appears in the bank account. The two can drift apart. The earnings quality card asks three questions: did the business bring in at least as much cash as the profit it reported? Does the core business earn its interest several times over? And how high is the tax rate? Each figure stands on its own; there is no score.

Cash flow divided by profit

Model company: operating cash flow €120 million, group profit €100 million → . From 1.0 the profit counts as covered by cash; below 0.8 it is clearly higher than the cash inflow. Then profit is often tied up in receivables or inventories, or a one-off gain without cash lifts it. Depreciation raises the ratio: it lowers profit but costs no cash in that year.

Interest cover

= operating income divided by interest expense. Model: €50 million against €5 million → 10.0 times. From 5 times the interest counts as well covered, below 2 times as thinly covered, in between as covered. If operating income is missing, we use pre-tax profit plus interest expense and label it.

Tax rate and exceptions

The is income taxes divided by pre-tax profit; the card shows it for information only. Model: €21 million tax on €100 million pre-tax profit → 21%. Companies with an unclassified balance sheet are excluded, above all banks and insurers: for them money is the product, so cash flow and interest measure something else.

More depth: how the card calculates

2 min read

All figures come from annual reports filed with the SEC. The card shows the last fiscal year; under “More depth” you find the calculation and a table of the last five fiscal years.

Group profit instead of net income

Operating cash flow covers the whole group, including the share of outside co-owners in subsidiaries. That is why we divide by group profit including these minority interests. If the company has no minority interests, both figures are the same.

Three years together

A single year can mislead, for example when customers pay a large invoice only in January. Next to it is therefore the value over three fiscal years: the sum of cash flows divided by the sum of profits, not the average of three ratios. It only appears if all three years have figures: for cash flow with a profit in every year, for interest and taxes also from the same source.

Very high ratios

If profit is tiny, the ratio becomes huge: €50 million cash flow on €2 million profit would give 25 times. The card then shows “over 10 times”, for interest cover from 100 times “over 100 times”. If interest income exceeds interest expense, that appears as a separate note.

Frequently asked questions

How do I recognise high earnings quality?

A common rule of thumb is operating cash flow at least as high as profit, so a ratio of 1.0 or more, over several years. A single weak year is common; a long run below 0.8 is a reason to take a closer look.

Why is the tax rate not rated?

Tax rates depend on country, loss carryforwards and special effects. A low rate can be lasting or one-off. That is why the card shows it for information only, without a threshold.

Is earnings quality a fifth quality check?

No. The four quality checks stay unchanged. Earnings quality is an additional fact card without points and without a score, free for everyone.

Quick check

See earnings quality on a stock page →

↑ ↓ select · Enter open · Esc close